Nobody Can Quite Say Why Google Business Profiles Matter, Only That They Do

Moz's much-quoted rundown of "local search ranking factors" has been circulating for years, though which year exactly is anyone's guess, and it applies to any small practice hoping a patient or client finds them on Google before they find someone else.

Whole-practice growth for wellness practices. Rooted in Wiltshire, UK, working worldwide.

Practices with a physical location or a service area live or die by local search, whether or not anyone can prove precisely how the ranking works.

Original ResearchA widely shared checklist of what supposedly pushes a business up or down in local Google results, put together by Moz.
Sourcehttps://moz.com/local-search-ranking-factors
OverviewA perennial industry reference on local SEO, published by Moz, a search marketing software company, though the underlying survey and its date are not made clear on the page.
YearNot disclosed
PublisherBrand, Moz
Relevance to WellbeingAny coach, therapist, healer, trainer, clinic or centre with a Google listing is playing this game whether they meant to or not, so the general principle applies even where the specifics can't be checked.
Our VerdictToo early to tell the broad idea rings true, but there is no disclosed methodology behind it, just a brand's confident list.
Our Summary
  • The general thrust, that Google profiles and reviews matter for being found locally, matches everything else known about local search.
  • No sample size, no survey date, and no named methodology, which is a lot of nothing for something quoted so often.
  • It costs nothing to keep a Google Business Profile complete and current, regardless of whether this particular list is gospel.
  • Treating an unattributed industry claim as hard evidence is exactly the kind of thing that gets a marketing agency a stern email.
Our Geo ViewApplies broadly to all countries, though how Google actually weighs these factors varies by market and isn't published anywhere either.
Abstract of wellbeing niches and revenue flow
Recognise how this might impact your practice

Why this might matter to you

  • Coaching: this matters because most coaching clients start with a search, not a referral, whatever the referral network likes to think.
  • Therapy: this matters because a therapist who's hard to find online is, functionally, a therapist who isn't taking new clients.
  • Training: this matters because people searching "personal trainer near me" are not going to scroll to page three.
  • Alternative Healing: this matters because word of mouth still needs Google to back it up before anyone books.
  • Clinical: this matters because patients check a profile before they check credentials, in that order, sadly.
  • Retreat/Centre: this matters because a centre's whole business model rests on being findable by people who've never heard of it before.

Where this came from

Moz's page lists what it reckons moves a business up or down in local search, without saying who was surveyed, when, or how many of them there were.

Moz, publish date not stated on the page. The claim is not independently sourced elsewhere and reads as the agency's own compiled view.

Credibility flags: methodology not disclosed, sample size not disclosed, publisher type Brand.

How we scored this

A relevance score out of 100, built from three things: how well it fits the six practice types, how recent it is, and how solid the methodology behind it is.

13%
Practice fit, 25How new, 10How solid, 0

Marked down heavily on how solid the method is, given there isn't one to inspect, and marked down on recency because the vintage of the claim can't be established either; practice fit sits in the middle since this is general local-business advice rather than anything wellbeing-specific.

Faces of satisfied clients
It's worth considering changes to your marketing practices

What this means for your marketing

  • Claim your Google Business Profile this week, if you haven't already, and fill in every field it offers, including the ones that feel pointless.
  • Ask your last three happy clients for a Google review before you ask them for anything else.
  • Put your practice's opening hours, address and phone number in the same format everywhere online, not four slightly different ways.
  • Brief your team that "we're on page one of Google" is a nice sentence, not a strategy, and needs checking every few months.
  • Say plainly to clients who ask, that there's no secret formula here, just steady upkeep of the basics.

Who this is most useful for

Practice typeRelevanceRecommended action
CoachingMediumKeep the Google profile current and collect reviews after sessions.
TherapyMediumEnsure listing details match across directories and the practice's own site.
TrainingHighPrioritise local profile completeness given the "near me" nature of searches.
Alternative HealingMediumUse reviews to back up word-of-mouth referrals online.
Clinical PracticesMediumAudit listing accuracy quarterly, particularly opening hours.
Retreats/CentresHighTreat the Google profile as a primary discovery channel, not an afterthought.

Best before

Best before: revisit whenever Moz next updates this page, and in the meantime verify any specific figure against Moz's own site directly at moz.com before quoting it as evidence.

What next?

Every practice owner who's ever wondered why the clinic down the road outranks them despite doing less good work will recognise this one.

Talk to us about Whole-practice Marketing

Therapy Space

The Thoughtful Ones Always Make It To The Bottom.

Well done, thinker. We love thinkers and they love our careful ways - our listening wind, story garden and visual river are all waiting for you in a twenty-five-minute coffee conversation that helps you rekindle faith in growing your practice. Milk and sugar?

Find your Sunlight  ▶
≡